Choosing the right Etsy SEO tool can make or break your listing strategy. The wrong tool gives you estimated data and sends you chasing keywords that don't convert. The right one shows you what buyers are actually searching for and helps you act on it fast.
The Etsy SEO tool market has gotten crowded. There are now over a dozen options ranging from free Chrome extensions to full-featured web platforms charging $30+ per month. Some focus purely on keyword research. Others handle analytics, listing management, and shop tracking. A few try to do everything.
This comparison cuts through the noise. We tested the most popular Etsy SEO tools available in 2026, evaluated them on data accuracy, feature set, usability, and value, and laid out exactly what each one does well and where it falls short.
What to Look For in an Etsy SEO Tool
Before diving into specific tools, here's what actually matters when choosing one:
Real data vs. estimates. Some tools pull actual search volume from marketplace data. Others use AI models to estimate search volume. The difference matters — estimated data can be off by 50% or more, which means you're optimizing for keywords that may not drive the traffic you expect.
Speed of workflow. Research is only valuable if you act on it. Tools that let you generate tags and apply them directly to your listing (without switching tabs, copying to spreadsheets, or manual re-typing) save hours per week for active sellers.
Multi-marketplace support. If you sell on Etsy, Amazon, and Redbubble, paying for three separate tools gets expensive fast. Tools that cover multiple platforms from one dashboard offer better value.
Trending data. Static keyword volumes tell you what was popular. Trending data tells you what's becoming popular. The sellers who catch trends early get the traffic before competition arrives.
Free tier quality. Many sellers start with fewer than 50 listings. A generous free plan lets you validate the tool before committing money.
The Tools Compared
Magic Tags
Type: Chrome extension (free + Pro) Pricing: Free plan available; Pro starts at $7/month Marketplaces: Etsy, Amazon, Redbubble
Magic Tags works as a Chrome extension that generates optimized tags directly while you're browsing Etsy, Amazon, or Redbubble. Enter a keyword or paste a competitor URL and it returns 13 optimized tags ranked by real search volume and competition data.
What it does well: The biggest advantage is workflow speed. Because it runs inside your browser, you never leave your listing editor. The free plan includes the tag generator, title generator, search volume data, and unlimited searches with no credit card required. Pro adds a trending dashboard with hourly updates, one-click auto-fill (tags populate directly into your listing), bulk tag management for updating hundreds of listings at once, and extended tag suggestions beyond the standard 13.
The trending dashboard is particularly strong. It surfaces emerging keywords before they peak, which is valuable for print-on-demand and digital product sellers who need to create designs around rising trends. Multi-marketplace support means Etsy, Amazon (FBA, Merch, KDP), and Redbubble sellers can use one tool instead of three.
Where it falls short: Magic Tags is focused on keyword research and listing optimization. It doesn't offer shop analytics, revenue tracking, or competitor shop monitoring that some web-based platforms provide. If you need a full business analytics dashboard, you'll need to pair it with another tool.
Best for: Sellers who want fast, data-driven tag generation and listing optimization without leaving their browser. Especially strong for multi-platform sellers and anyone managing high listing volumes.
eRank
Type: Web platform (free + paid) Pricing: Free plan; paid plans from $9.99/month Marketplaces: Etsy
eRank is one of the oldest Etsy SEO tools and has a large user base. It offers keyword research, listing audits, shop analytics, trend tracking, and competition analysis through a web-based dashboard.
What it does well: eRank's strength is breadth. It covers keyword research, listing optimization scores, shop stats, competition monitoring, and trending searches all in one platform. The free plan is functional enough for casual sellers. The listing audit feature grades your listings on tag usage, title structure, and other SEO factors, which is helpful for sellers who are new to optimization.
Where it falls short: The data is estimated rather than pulled from real marketplace sources. Several independent tests have shown eRank's search volume numbers can diverge significantly from actual Etsy search data. The interface is also dated and can feel overwhelming with the amount of menus and options. Workflow speed is a weak point — you research keywords on eRank's website, then manually copy tags back into your Etsy listing. There's no direct integration or auto-fill capability. It's also Etsy-only, so Amazon and Redbubble sellers need separate tools.
Best for: Sellers who want an all-in-one Etsy dashboard with shop analytics and don't mind manually transferring keyword research to their listings.
Everbee
Type: Chrome extension (free + paid) Pricing: Free plan; paid plans from $9.99/month Marketplaces: Etsy
Everbee focuses on product research and revenue estimation rather than pure keyword optimization. It shows estimated monthly revenue, sales counts, and pricing data for Etsy listings directly in search results.
What it does well: Product research is Everbee's core strength. If you're trying to validate whether a product niche is profitable before creating designs or inventory, Everbee gives you estimated revenue and sales data overlaid right on Etsy search results. This is useful for niche research and competitive analysis. The Chrome extension format means it works directly in your workflow.
Where it falls short: Everbee is primarily a product research tool, not a keyword optimization tool. Its tag generation features are limited compared to dedicated SEO tools. Revenue estimates are modeled (not actual sales data) and can be inaccurate for shops with irregular pricing or promotional patterns. If your primary need is tag optimization and keyword research, Everbee alone won't be enough.
Best for: Sellers doing product validation and niche research who want revenue estimates before entering a market. Often used alongside a dedicated keyword tool.
Marmalead
Type: Web platform (paid only) Pricing: From $19/month Marketplaces: Etsy
Marmalead has been in the Etsy SEO space for years and focuses heavily on keyword research and listing optimization with a guided approach.
What it does well: Marmalead's "Entrepreneur" workflow walks sellers through keyword research step by step, which is helpful for beginners who don't know where to start. The keyword comparison feature lets you evaluate multiple keywords side by side. The engagement and competition scores give a quick snapshot of keyword viability.
Where it falls short: No free plan — you're paying $19/month from day one with no way to test before committing. Like eRank, the data is estimated rather than based on real search volumes. The web-based workflow means you research on Marmalead's site and then manually apply findings to your Etsy listings. Interface design feels dated compared to newer tools. Etsy-only with no support for Amazon or Redbubble.
Best for: Etsy-only sellers who prefer a guided, educational approach to keyword research and are comfortable with the price point.
Sale Samurai
Type: Web platform (paid only) Pricing: From $9.99/month Marketplaces: Etsy
Sale Samurai offers keyword research, listing optimization, and shop analytics with a focus on search volume data and competition metrics.
What it does well: Competitive pricing for the features offered. Keyword research includes search volume estimates, competition scores, and related keyword suggestions. The listing optimizer scores your existing listings and suggests improvements. Decent trend tracking for seasonal planning.
Where it falls short: Smaller user base means less community support and fewer tutorials. Data accuracy has been questioned in comparison tests. Web-based workflow without direct listing integration. Etsy-only. The interface is functional but not as polished as some competitors.
Best for: Budget-conscious Etsy sellers who want basic keyword research and listing scoring at a lower price point than Marmalead.
EtsyHunt
Type: Web platform (free + paid) Pricing: Free plan; paid plans available Marketplaces: Etsy
EtsyHunt focuses on product and shop research with tools for analyzing top shops, trending products, and niche opportunities.
What it does well: Strong shop analysis features. You can browse top-performing shops by category, see their best-selling products, and analyze their tag strategies. The trending products section surfaces items gaining traction. Free plan offers enough to get started with basic research.
Where it falls short: More of a research and scouting tool than an optimization tool. Tag generation and listing optimization features are limited. No direct integration with your Etsy listing editor. Data coverage and accuracy vary by category.
Best for: Sellers doing competitive research and shop scouting to identify successful niches and strategies.
Redbubble-Specific Tools (Merch Titans, BubbleTrends, TopBubbleIndex)
Type: Web platforms (various pricing) Marketplaces: Redbubble
Several tools focus specifically on Redbubble optimization. Merch Titans offers keyword research and niche analysis for Redbubble and Amazon Merch. BubbleTrends and TopBubbleIndex track trending designs and keywords on Redbubble.
What they do well: Deep Redbubble-specific data that general Etsy tools don't offer. Trending design categories, niche saturation analysis, and Redbubble-specific keyword research. Valuable for sellers who primarily sell on Redbubble.
Where they fall short: Single-platform focus. If you sell on Etsy and Amazon too, you need additional tools. Most have smaller development teams, so feature updates and data freshness may lag behind larger platforms.
Best for: Dedicated Redbubble sellers who want platform-specific trending data and niche research.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Feature
Magic Tags
eRank
Everbee
Marmalead
Sale Samurai
Free plan
Yes (generous)
Yes (limited)
Yes (limited)
No
No
Real search data
Yes
Estimated
Estimated
Estimated
Estimated
Tag generator
13+ tags
Manual research
Limited
Manual research
Manual research
Auto-fill to listing
Yes (Pro)
No
No
No
No
Bulk operations
Yes (Pro)
No
No
No
No
Trending dashboard
Yes (hourly)
Basic
No
Basic
Basic
Multi-marketplace
Etsy, Amazon, RB
Etsy only
Etsy only
Etsy only
Etsy only
Shop analytics
No
Yes
Yes (revenue)
Limited
Yes
Chrome extension
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
Starting price
Free / $7 Pro
Free / $9.99
Free / $9.99
$19
$9.99
Which Tool Should You Use?
The right choice depends on where you are in your selling journey and what your primary need is:
If you need fast, accurate tag optimization: Magic Tags. The Chrome extension workflow, real search data, and auto-fill capability make it the fastest path from keyword research to optimized listing. The free plan is the most generous in the category, and multi-marketplace support means you don't need separate tools for Amazon and Redbubble.
If you want a full Etsy business dashboard: eRank. It covers keyword research, shop analytics, competition monitoring, and listing audits in one platform. The trade-off is estimated data and a manual workflow.
If you're validating product niches: Everbee. Revenue and sales estimates help you decide whether a niche is worth entering before you invest time in designs or inventory. Pair it with a dedicated keyword tool for tag optimization.
If you're a complete beginner: Marmalead's guided workflow teaches you the fundamentals of Etsy SEO. Once you understand the basics, you may outgrow it and want a faster, data-driven tool.
If you sell primarily on Redbubble: Combine Magic Tags (for keyword research across platforms) with a Redbubble-specific tool like Merch Titans or BubbleTrends for niche and trending data.
Many serious sellers use two tools: one for keyword research and listing optimization (where speed and data accuracy matter most) and one for shop analytics and competitive intelligence. The tools aren't mutually exclusive.
The Bottom Line
The Etsy SEO tool you choose should make your workflow faster, not slower. It should show you real data, not estimates. And it should grow with you as your shop scales from 10 listings to 10,000.
Start with a free plan, optimize a handful of listings, and measure the results. The right tool will show its value within the first week.
Try data-driven tag optimization for free. Get Magic Tags →
Related reading:
