MagicTags vs eRank: Which Etsy Tool Is Right for You?
eRank is the most popular free Etsy analytics platform. MagicTags is a Chrome extension that generates optimized tags and titles from live search data.
MagicTags generates optimized tags and titles in real time from live marketplace search results. eRank provides historical Etsy analytics including keyword explorer, listing audits, and shop stats. Many sellers use both.
| Feature | MagicTags | eRank |
|---|---|---|
| Data Source | Live marketplace search (real-time) | Historical database (delayed) |
| Tag Generation | Yes — 13 optimized tags per search | Limited tag suggestions |
| Title Generation | Yes — SEO-optimized titles | No |
| One-Click Auto-Fill | Yes (Pro) | No |
| Multi-Marketplace | Etsy, Amazon, Redbubble | Etsy only |
| Interface | Chrome extension | Web dashboard |
| Free Plan | Yes | Yes |
| Pro Price | $15/mo or $55/yr | $5.99/mo+ |
Where MagicTags Wins
MagicTags is purpose-built for the listing workflow.
- Real-time data
- One-click auto-fill
- Title generation
- Multi-marketplace
- Chrome extension
Where eRank Wins
eRank is a broader analytics platform.
- Shop stats dashboard
- Listing audit tool
- Historical keyword data
- Competitor analysis
- Larger free plan
Using Both Together
Use eRank to analyze performance, then use MagicTags to generate optimized tags and titles.
Frequently Asked Questions
They're different tools. MagicTags excels at tag/title generation. eRank excels at analytics. Many sellers use both.
eRank provides keyword suggestions, but doesn't generate a complete set of 13 optimized tags in one click.
No. eRank is Etsy-only. MagicTags supports all three marketplaces.
Generate Tags from What's Ranking Right Now
MagicTags uses live marketplace data — not historical databases.
Get MagicTags Free